Answer: I wish I had a better answer to your question. It
is tough to overcome bad coaches anywhere.
If you lived in my community here in Ponte Vedra,
Florida, I would have a solution for you. A few years ago after years of
coaching in Long Island Midget Football and Pop Warner football, I started
a unique recreational program as an alternative to those "highly
competitive" programs. This is a tackle football program for 125
players between the ages of 6 and 14 that focuses on fun, participation
and skill development for every player.. Players receive instruction and
playing time at all positions including the skill positions. Players play
extensively because of small rosters sizes. We practice twice a week for
an hour and 45 minutes and players enjoy practice as much as games.
Balanced competition is a priority and our coaches coach all the children
so they have no stake in who wins the games. Parents, coaches and players
alike love the experience.
But you don't live here and from what you have
said there aren't any alternative programs. The best thing you can do is
try to change the mind set of the coaches of your existing group.
How many parents feel the way you do? You said
that 5 kids have quit already and the team is down to 19. That may
work in your favor when trying to have an influence on the coaches.
If there are 5 or 6 parents who recognize and
feel strongly about the problems you have cited, perhaps if you joined
together you could threaten to take your kids off the team unless the
coaches change their ways.
Most football leagues require teams have a
minimum of 18 or 20 players. If 6 more quit, the group might have to fold
and I'm sure the coaches don't want that to happen. Check with the league
officials on the minimum required players.
To achieve a change you should discuss your
complaints with the group of coaches or at least the head coach. Let
him/them know what they are doing that you disapprove of and what would
constitute improved behavior. Unfortunately bad coaches don't agree that
they are bad. They feel justified in what they do claiming discipline,
team unity, etc. It's unfortunate that it has to come to this. From
what you describe though, the coaches are indeed abusive, demeaning and
insensitive. I would not allow them to coach in our program.
One other thing you might consider is to
complain/explain to the community officials, the mayor, the town
supervisor or the school board that controls the field the team plays and
practices on. Most teams play on community owned fields or school fields.
Explain your concerns that the coaches are abusive and request that field
permits be lifted. It might help to write a letter to the editor of the
local newspaper. Community/school officials may be more responsive if such
pressure is applied.
By the way, if none of this helps and the coaches
continue to be abusive, I would not hesitate to taking your child off the
team. I wish I could offer more help.